Traditional Christmas Dinner Buying Guide, Stores, and Prices
Contents[Hide]

Traditional Christmas Dinner

Though a traditional Christmas dinner may not be as rigidly traditional as the prior month's Thanksgiving meal, there are certainly precedents to adhere to and rules to follow. This guide will give you the Christmas Day lunch and dinner basics. Here, you can learn what foods are surefire ways to impress your guests and some acceptable culinary deviations off the beaten path.

The Main Course

Like Thanksgiving, turkey is a traditional Christmas favorite for American families. However, it is not the only dish that can serve as center stage on Christmas. Many families prefer a ham, while others opt for a tasty pheasant or a goose.

Turkey

Turkey  is the meat of choice for many families on Christmas. It can be prepared a number of ways, can feed a large number of people, and always leaves plenty of leftovers.

  • As with Thanksgiving, plan on about a pound of turkey for everyone. Even if that seems to small a portion for some, there will be plenty of side dishes to go around.
  • Many families prefer smoked turkey  on Christmas, as to avoid a Thanksgiving redux.
  • Plan ahead, turkey can take days to cook. A frozen turkey  must defrost. Even a fresh one  is not picnic-ready.
  • Teriyaki marinade  is an unexpected, but fantastic, way to surprise your guests.
  • You could also break up the bird and diversify your preparation. See AskMen.com's Christmas Dinner guide.

Christmas Ham

Ham  is certainly the number two choice on the Christmas menu. It is a versatile meat that can be prepared in a number of ways. Here are some guidelines to follow.

Goose

Goose may not be as popular as it was a century ago, but it is still the classic bird of Christmas. If you are going for a truly formal and historically traditional American holiday, then the goose should be your bird of choice on the 25th.

  • Roasting a goose  is relatively easy (it is prepared quite like turkey) and very rewarding. Check out MSNBC's Guide on Roast Goose for more detail.
  • Goose usually has to be specially ordered from a butcher or online. Fresh is best.
  • Don't be afraid to serve less traditional side dishes with this traditional main course; wild rice  or a variety of roasted vegetables can change your outlook on this old-fashioned bird.

Roast Beef

Roast beef is a fundamental part of a traditional Northeastern Christmas dinner. Roast beef takes time to prepare, so keep that in mind when thinking about menu choices.

  • Roast beef is a juicy alternative to dry poultry or sweet glazed ham.
  • Leftover roast beef is just as delicious as it is at its first tasting, making for some fantastic sandwiches.
  • Use a rich beef gravy  to create a truly savory meal.

Other Meat Options

In addition to goose and turkey, there are plenty of other meats that can satisfy the holiday bird/beast urge.

  • Pheasant  is a popular bird for a small Christmas dinner. Brining, barding, and braising are the most popular methods of cooking this meat, which has a dryer taste than most alternatives. Get a recipe and go to work.
  • Quail  is a traditional Victorian-style Christmas bird. It is usually roasted and served alongside turkey, rather than as an alternative main dish.
  • Boar  may not be the first thing that comes to mind when you hear "Christmas dinner," but in Medieval England, it was the dish of the day. If you're planning a huge feast, it might be a practical (and surprisingly yummy) option.

Popular Side Dishes

Christmas side dishes mirror the traditional main courses: they read like an expanded Thanksgiving menu. Mix and match your favorite winter foods, but always keep your entree in mind when picking sides. Accompany ham with sweet dishes, like roasted fruit. For juicy meats (like boar and roast beef), potatoes and other absorbent foods will do the trick. There are obviously dozens of options, but here are some of the most popular and easy-to-prepare among them.

Side Dishes

Corn  has been a traditional American dish since the country was founded.

Cranberry sauce  is a good side for any holiday entree.

Roasted chestnuts  evoke an image of Christmas more than any other side dish.

Mashed potatoes  are perfect with boar or roast beef. They can soak up the juices.

Warm rolls  with butter spread are a delightful meal starter.

Ever More Choices

Green beans are a tender, crisp way to add a little green to your holiday menu.

Roast potatoes  make a sublime pair with either pheasant or goose or any juicy meat dish.

Roasted apples  are generally suggested as a side for a ham entree.

Sweet glazed carrots  partner nicely with ham, but complement turkey, too.

Mushrooms  go well with roast beef and other dishes. They also make a delicious starter.


And Still More Options

Candied yams  are a tasty treat that can really add some flavor to bird entrees.

Steamed cabbage  is traditionally served with roast beef, ham, or boar.

Creamed spinach  is a versatile side dish that works with any entree.

Roasted asparagus  can add some elegance to your meal.

Broccoli  is versatile side that will fit on any plate. As a starter or closer, it works.

Delectable Desserts

Okay, so the meal is done and everyone's buttons are bursting off their shirts, but the fun has only just begun. Yuletide desserts are among the most delicious seasonal treats available. While you can't go wrong with normal sweets like chocolate cake, chocolate chip cookies, fudge, or iced sugar cookies, there are several special items that are best eaten around the holidays. These will keep your guests satisfied with warm, full bellies, and they'll make your home smell heavenly too.

Top-Notch Desserts

Yule Log

Aw, the timeless yule log . For pure chocolate and creme goodness, it beats all the competition. It looks nice too.

Plum Pudding

Plum pudding  is a formal holiday treat that is both tasty and classy. Just keep it away from the little ones, as this dish can be pretty heavy in the alcohol content.

Fruitcake

Fruitcake  may be the butt of many a Christmas joke, but give it a try. It looks festive enough, right? For a less rum-soaked option, try Panettone .

Gingerbread Cookies

Gingerbread cookies  are perfect for the holiday season. They're decorative and delicious! Make them yourself for an added personal touch.

Bread Pudding

Bread pudding  is a classic holiday dessert in a number of cultural traditions. Try a liquor-based recipe and enjoy.

What To Drink

Last, but certainly not least, the holidays provide yet another excuse to sit down, relax, and have a few after-dinner drinks with the people you cherish the most: your family. There is plenty to drink on Christmas Day, if your blood alcohol level hasn't already been given a boost between brandy-soaked desserts  and port-based sauces . Here is a short list of suggestions.

Holiday Drinks

Eggnog

Eggnog is the quintessential Christmas drink . It's easy to find and tastes delicious, but be sure to keep the special Grownup eggnog away from the kids.

Christmas Beer

Many beer manufacturers make specially spiced holiday and Christmas beers .

Mulling Spices

Mulling spices  will give cider and wine an extra holiday kick. Just don't forget to filter  the spices out after the seasoning has been added.

Christmas Champagne

Champagne  isn't just for New Year's Eve. Break a bottle out early and enjoy the day or slip a little into your orange juice for holiday mimosas.

Rum

Spiced rum  can be added to any hot drink to bring that Christmas warmth home.

Tips for a Successful Christmas Dinner

For more information on this subject, see our guide to Hosting a Christmas Party.

  • Tackling Christmas dinner is obviously a huge task, so plan ahead to make sure you have a guest headcount and are aware of any dietary restrictions well before the date. You'll have enough things to do right before the party, and you certainly don't want to be caught rushing around to shops last minute.
  • Give your guests plenty of advance notice so they can plan accordingly, especially if you're planning a potluck.
  • Come up with a budget. If you have a basic idea of how much everything should cost, you will be less likely to overspend. Keep your budget handy and consult it frequently to make sure you're still on track.
  • Enlist your friends and family to help. If you are hosting, you can absolutely ask people to contribute a dish, help with setting up and cleaning, and so on. If people offer assistance, accept it!
  • Be aware of the fact that some people run on a different schedule, and thus they might arrive late. Consider having a cocktail hour  with a few hors d'oeuvres, some board games, or other activities--this way, your guests will be amused and won't starve while you wait for stragglers.
  • Christmas is all about spending time with loved ones, so incorporate your family traditions, where possible. Your guests will appreciate this intimacy, and they might get ideas for their own future holidays.
  • Prep and cook as much food as you can the night before. The better prepared you are, the more in control you will feel on the day of the party.
  • Make sure you take some time for you on the day of the party. Give yourself at least a half hour to sit and unwind so you're fresh and relaxed when everyone arrives. This is a celebration, not a chore, so be sure you're able to enjoy everything as much as your guests do.

Related Guides

Secret Santa Exchanges

Indoor Christmas Decorations

Vegetarian Christmas

Holiday Safety

Christmas Music

Leave Your Comments, Questions, Opinions!