Contents[Hide]

Cooktops

Drop-in cooktops are becoming more popular, especially for new construction or kitchen renovation projects. Although separate cooktops and wall ovens are more expensive than a single range, the independent units allow for an almost unlimited configuration of kitchen appliances. Getting a separate cooktop also allows you to get a vertical double wall oven, which can come in handy if you entertain often.

Recommendations

There are three kinds of cooktops: gas, electric and induction. ConsumerSearch recommends the following models. (Prices are approximate.)

Kenmore 42732 

30" Electric Smoothtop
$450

Kenmore 42742 

36" Electric Smoothtop
$600

Maytag MGC6536 

36" Gas
$650

Magic Chef CGC2536 

36" Budget Gas
$320

Kenmore Elite 42800 

Induction
$1650



Gas Cooktops

  • Pros:
    • Fine control of temperature and flame levels, which is much easier to see than on a smooth top electric range.
    • Can be shut off immediately with little heat retention, reducing the risk of burning yourself or others.
    • Can be used even during power outages (with a match -- use caution).
  • Cons:
    • Not as efficient as electric or induction.
    • Need a gas line hookup and electricity.
  • Look For:
    • Functionally, most gas ranges are very similar; the differences are in the features.
    • Easy-cleaning features, such as removable grill and sealed burners.
    • Heavy, porcelain grates. Or as an alternative, continuous grates that span the whole cooktop (they can be harder to clean though).
    • Ceramic surfaces.
    • Multiple burner sizes for different sizes of pots and pans.
    • Easy-to-use knobs.
    • "X-Lo" Feature: Burner will automatically turn on and off at set intervals to keep your sauce warm but not boiling. Also called a simmer burner on some models.
    • Sealed burners and removable burner pans.
    • Electric ignition -- easier and more reliable than a pilot light.

Electric Cooktops

  • Pros:
    • More efficient than gas stoves.
    • Doesn't need a separate gas line since it just plugs in.
    • Flat-top electric ranges are very easy to clean, fast to heat up, aesthetically pleasing, and offer more versatility with expanding elements (for a small sauce pan or a large frying pan on one burner space).
    • Coil electrics are cheaper than smooth-top ranges, but it is relatively easy to replace the coil elements if they break.
  • Cons:
    • Older-style coil ranges take a while to cool so you can burn yourself easily.
    • Control is not as fine as a gas range, especially with coil models.
    • Gas is considered more precise and is preferred by professional cooks.
  • Look For:
    • Functionally, most electric ranges within a given category (coil or flat) are functionally very similar; the differences are in the features.
    • Easy cleaning surfaces.
    • Safety switches that prevent toddlers from turning on the stove.
    • Porcelain drip pans are easy to clean and retain their luster.
    • Easy-to-use controls.

Induction Cooktops

  • Pros:
    • Surface never gets warm, but pots and pans heat up quickly. (See picture for a demo!)
      • Reduces risk of fire, burnt-on spills and accidentally injuring children.
    • Easy to clean, smooth surface.
    • Heats pans faster than other kinds of ranges.
    • Extremely energy efficient -- almost all the heat generated is in the pan itself, keeping your kitchen cooler and your energy bills lower.
  • Cons:
    • Very new technology; not fully tested.
    • Need pans and pots made of a magnetizable material -- copper and aluminum will not work.
    • Expensive (at least $2000), although prices may come down in the near future.
  • Look For:
    • There are only two or three full-sized cooktop models currently on the market.
    • All performed well in tests, but the Kenmore Elite 480  is the least expensive.

Related Products

Wall Ovens

Ranges

Kitchen Hoods 

Pots and Pans

Potholders 

External Links


▼ Advertisement ▼