Comic Books Buying Guide, Stores, and Prices
Contents[Hide]

Comic Books

By riverajessica

Who doesn't love relaxing in a bean bag  with a great comic book  in hand? You don't have to be a walking, talking basement-dwelling stereotype to enjoy these tomes; as American Splendor author Harvey Pekar was often heard to say, "Comics are words and pictures. You can do anything with words and pictures." Whether you're a hardcore reader or a casual one, there's no time like the present to start your own collection or to give some themed gifts.

Origin Story

Comic books  have a longer history than just Spider-Man ; by some standards, he's still a baby. Comics as a story telling format date back to the mid-1600's, the so-called Victorian Age, but it wasn't until the late-1800's that comics assumed a more recognizable aesthetic in the form of comic strips in newspapers, which were later reprinted in album form. These were the early beginnings of the modern comic book.

The Golden Age of comics began in 1938. Action Comics #1 introduced Superman  and the action hero  world exploded with mythology-inspired characters like The Flash  and Aquaman . By the end of World War II, superheroes largely died out, and the Atomic Age of crime and horror comics had started to evolve.

Superpowered heroes were revived in 1956 with the advent of the Silver Age of comics. Here Spider-Man ,Daredevil ,Fantastic 4 ,Iron Man , and The Hulk  were introduced to the world . Around this time the underground Comix scene began to flourish as well, with a focus on countercultural concepts restricted by the Comics Code Authority. It is also during this time that comics began influencing Pop Art, with Roy Lichtenstein using Ben-Day dots to create a comic strip appearance on large single panel pieces.

The period from 1970 to 1980 was known as the Bronze Age, where many new books were created and the face of the industry was transformed with the talent of a lot of young guns. Between the Bronze and Silver Ages, mainstream publications moved from optimistic, if sometimes goofy, diversions to socially aware entertainment. Since that time, some combination of "BAM! WHAM! POW! Comics are growing up!" has been used to describe the changing medium.

Lastly we have the Modern Age, which has spanned from 1980 to the present day. Also known as the age of grim and gritty storytelling, and sometimes broken down into the Dark Age, the last few decades have seen event storylines like the Death of Superman, the rebooting of various comic universes, and the rise of the antihero. The last few years specifically have let up on the latter aspect, though a preference for conflicted characters remains.

Comic Book Companies

There is no shortage of masked men or a caped heroes saving the local populace from costumed menaces; the two major brands that compete for the top spot in this superhero  world are DC and Marvel, with Image and Dark Horse competing for third. Fantagraphics, another major publisher, focuses more on older forms, with noir and horror genres and comprehensive collections of classics like Krazy Kat  and Peanuts. Below are some of the more popular or enduring titles from each company. Intimidated by the long, complicated histories of Batman or the X-Men? Consider DC's Showcase Presents  or Marvel's Essentials  series to get some of the basics for popular characters. 

DC

Marvel

Image

Fantagraphics 

Dark Horse 

Superhero Must-Reads

These are the shining stars of superhero comics, the ones fans and critics point to when dissenters say the medium has no merit. List below is just a few of the many the hero-centered tales; beyond that is a variety of worthy titles that explore the world beyond crime fighters and their rogue's galleries.

Marvels 

A view of the Golden and Silver ages of the Marvel Universe from the perspective of an average citizen.

The Spirit 

A genre-crossing series with noir, mystery, drama, and comedic influences. The ultimate pulp hero.

Sandman 

The story of the Lord of Dreams; well regarded for its literary and mythological allusions.

The Dark Knight Returns 

A cold, hard look at Batman, the DC Universe, and superheroes in general set in the eighties.

Watchmen 

Another Cold War-influenced take on superheroes, and easily the most well-known one. 

Don't Need Another Hero

But what if masked men in spandex aren't your deal? Fear not, there are tons of series out there that don't focus on traditional hero tales; these range from coming-of-age stories to the supernatural.

Fables 

The evil Adversary forces fairy tale characters to emigrate to New York; mystery and mayhem ensue.

Scott Pilgrim 

A young man from Canada must finally grow up. Oh, and his girlfriend's exes are trying to kill him.

Bone 

A dark and funny epic that's said to rival the Lord of the Rings in scope. Suitable for kids, worthwhile for adults.

Chew 

In a world where chicken is illegal, cibopath Tony Chu solves crimes for the FDA.

Ghost World 

Two cynical teen girls mock nineties pop culture and drift through young adulthood, eventually maturing.

Indie Comics

While there's nothing precluding any of the above from being well-written or deeply touching, the stories below have a much firmer grip on reality, pockmarks and all.  Beautifully drawn, heartbreaking and sometimes bitterly funny, these books tell personal tales that will move even the most hardened of adults.

Persepolis 

A graphic novel detailing author Marjane Satrapi's experiences growing up in Iran during the Cultural Revolution.

Maus 

Art Spiegelman tells the story of his father, a Holocaust survivor, with honesty and dark humor.

Love and Rockets 

A richly told series that follows the personal lives of several punk Latinas, known to readers as Las Locas.

American Splendor 

A comic series from Harvey Pekar and R. Crumb that largely centers on the former's daily life.

Fun Home: a Family Tragedy 

A spiraling tale of family and life in a rural town, with a focus on author Alison Bechdel's complicated relationship with her dad.

Comic Books as Gifts

You can't just pick up any old superhero story and expect your comic-loving friend to fall at your feet in awe.  If you're trying to pick out a present for a superfan, there are a few pieces of advice you'll want to follow.

  • Do your research! Find out what the recipient tends to read and what the particular type of comic that you want to buy is worth.
    • Find out the person's level of interest in comics:
      • Does he or she like certain characters  best?
      • Specific writers or artists?
      • See if he or she has a collection going and which titles are missing from it.
    • If you are already into comic books yourself, finding a good read won't be difficult.  You may already know some great Web sites where you can find advice on back issues, pricing, auctions, and more. You might even have a subscription to a comic book magazine, so consult that for more guidance.
    • If you are a newbie, be sure to talk over your purchasing possibilities with a knowledgeable salesperson and do some research ahead of time, too. There's nothing wrong with being prepared to bargain for that one-of-a-kind comic that you just have to get your hands on.
    • Keep it age appropriate. Kids probably shouldn't be reading The Dark Night Returns  and an adult collector might be annoyed by something from the Little Archie  collection.

Comic Books for Kids

Comic books are an excellent gift for kids, especially those that aren't big into reading--think of them as a gateway drug to greater literacy. Because the market is increasingly geared toward adult storytelling, finding fun and suitable stories for children can be a huge chore, but below are some of the top picks.

Big Fat Little Lit 

A best-of culled from Art Spiegleman's Little Lit collections, full of fun comics by one of the industry's best.

The Adventures of Tintin 

An international classic following the adventures of globe-trotting reporter Tintin and his dog Snowy. 

The Muppet Show 

A great way to pass your love of Jim Henson's creations on to a new generation. Be sure to look for spin-offs, like Muppet Sherlock Holmes .

Walt Disney 

Perfect for the youngest of the bunch. These are colorful, lighthearted comics; those interested in a meatier story should check out The Life and Times of Scrooge McDuck .

Archie Comics 

The ultimate American teenager, Archie and his friends have been a go-to kid-friendly comic for decades.

Don't forget international comics such as Asterix  (France) and the Smurfs  (Belgium). You can also find age-appropriate comics featuring superheroes from the Big Two, Marvel and DC, under their youth-comics imprints, Marvel Adventures  and Johnny DC , respectively.

Collecting Comic Books

From a collector's perspective, titles from the Modern Age basically have no value. Collectors hoarding large numbers anticipating a big boom in the collecting industry, along with company-created lures like holograms covers and reboots to make issues with a No. 1 label, have created an artificially high demand and rendered issues from this time period virtually worthless. The most valuable books range from the introduction of the superhero theme (Golden Age) to the end of the Bronze Age (1979).

  • Educate yourself on the industry. Research the titles, t-shirts ,toys ,posters  or other items  that you are looking for.
  • Get smart with the Comic Buyer's Guide magazine or download Robert M. Overstreet's Comic Book Price Guide (not a free download).
  • The best way to identify comics is through the indicia: a small block of text on the inside front cover or on the first page that contains the issue number, publication date and exact title.
  • Since heroes  often cross platforms and have multiple titles, the indicia is one of the true ways you can match information.
  • Remember that the most important element to collecting is the passion that you have for a particular series, character ,time period , or storyline .

Comic Book Grading

When buying or selling comic books, the item's condition is the most important factor in determining price. Books in the best condition will have little signs of wear, retain good color, and possess sharp edges and few creases. Often the buyer and seller will disagree over the exact condition--it's personal bias to grade something higher if you're selling it, and if you're buying, it's often the opposite. This can cause problems since there needs to be some sort of mutual agreement before the transaction, but luckily there is a service that provides independent grading.

  • Comics Guaranty is a third-party service specializing in comic book grading.
    • CGC will examine any comic book you submit to them, check for restoration, and give an opinion on the item's condition.
    • They also assign grades and place books in tamper-proof plastic.
    • Look for sales that have been graded by this service.

Related Guides

Leave Your Comments, Questions, Opinions!